Google hits back hard with its OpenSocial plans but will the user benefit?

Well, there it is. TechCrunch reported it first (but everyone else has the same scoop!). Google is now revealing its social networking plans. Under the projectname OpenSocial, Google will launch a new set of APIs that application developers can use across social networks. This is definitely good news for the application developers. Instead of having to invest in yet another markup language or platform API they can do it all with one API. Very smart Google. It also matches a lot of the speculations I had on their strategy. As Mathew Ingram points out very nicely, Google has created the one ring that binds them all.

But let us not forget what that “one ring” was about. The real power of it lies in the hands of the creator, not in the hands of the one that wears the ring! Of course Facebook and MySpace have figured out that one for themselves, so they won’t be inclined any soon to join this Google blow to their kneecaps. I’m watching John Battelles take on this, as I always like his analysis.

It does take away a lot of the hype around the attempt of Facebook to launch SocialAds (here and a good analysis here). If Google can claim this central position (and they certainly have the capabilities for it) then Facebook’s attempts to leverage their closed network of approx. 50Mln profiles will be completely wiped away by the “We have access to approximately ALL Internet users worldwide” Google effort.

But what about the user. Will he benefit in the end? I have written a lot about flaws in web 2.0 and some of my wishes to correct them. It remains to be seen if he actually benefits. For example, I haven’t seen anything on privacy in the leaked Google plans. That will be an interesting one, especially if Google gets access to not only web pages and user profiles, but might also be able to leverage my interactions. A scary thought indeed, unless I get to control my own privacy. But the greatest threat to the user in my opinion is whether these Google plans will increase ad pressure on the web user. I am not a big fan of the advertisement model that currently is used as the mainstream web 2.0 business model. It inherently creates walled gardens, limits my options as a user and provides me with often unwanted confrontations with advertisers.

Having said all this I still think the world is better off with Google introducing these OpenSocial plans. It will scare the hell out of current successful but walled garden platforms like Facebook and MySpace. it will fuel an explosion of new and more open innovations. That is definitely beneficial to the user. But a warning is in place for Google. It only took a 3 ft small hobit and a lot of will power to end the domination of the ring that tried to rule them all!


About vanelsas

See my about page, ;-)
This entry was posted in API, Facebook, Google, myspace, OpenSocial, Social Graph, social networks, SocialAds, web 2.0 and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Google hits back hard with its OpenSocial plans but will the user benefit?

  1. I darn near missed your closing sentence! How funny.

    What will be very interesting to me is the licensing terms. Will it be like Farcebook where developers can only borrow that data? Or is Google truly creating a new layer of people that sits above the individual siloes, with much more flexible usage rights?

    As I wrote in, the problem of a farcebook app is that you are only borrowing the user data and social graph, you never really own anything — which makes this less appealing to me as a business. As a result I see it only as an advertising opportunity, measured by conversion, etc.

    But as you know, there are many opportunities that open up as a result of breaking down the siloed walls.

  2. Kirill Bolgarov says:

    I agree, Alex. The user will benefit. Though I don’t think facebook and myspace users will abandon their profiles for the opensocial “hosts”. Maybe they will use both, but in the end, at most cases, they will remain at their good old walled garden. As you mentioned above, those will slow down with ad pressure and launch more features to show “how open the platform actually is”. But not more than needed to keep the users from leaving them. I wrote a small humble post on this, it’ll be a pleasure to see you guys comment to it…

  3. Alexander van Elsas says:

    @jordan, the problem with me is that I tend to get carried away while writing, so I’m surprised that you even got to the last sentence given the length of my posts 😉
    Yes, I agree. Licensing terms are crucial. If Google means business I’m pretty confident they will open up, otherwise there will be less incentives for application builders or service owners to join the party.
    Your link didn’t make it through. Can you repost so that we can look at it?

  4. Alexander van Elsas says:

    Kirill, happy to look at your post, can you provide the link?

    Actually, thinking about it. Facebook will probably do a balancing act, just like you suggest. Not really opening up, but suggesting they are. I think though that such a defensive strategy will probably not work. People won’t be fooled, and the Tech Blog community will light a fire discussing this once more open services appear. It is the tragedy of being the largest. You will always get attacked by every one, thus forcing you into a defensive position.

  5. Kirill Bolgarov says:

    oops sorry 🙂 I thought it would be available from my name

  6. Kirill Bolgarov says:

    I agree, Alex. The defensive position will not work for people like us. But FB has 50 mln users – most of them don’t care… They have fun and don’t want to look further than following friday…

  7. Here’s that link again. Yeah, you do go on a bit, don’t you! 😉

  8. Pingback: OpenSocial Advertising for All! « GigaOM

  9. Pingback: Can Google control the social web? « TaylorPost

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s