The competitive advantage Apple holds over Google isn’t iOS5 or iCloud


I followed the Apple WWDC 2011 conference yesterday via the live blogging service of Engadget and Twitter (wasn’t in SF at the time). You can find an overview of all things announced here. The expectations were high upfront. Everyone seems to expect no less than a new miracle from Steve Jobs and his company. I thought it was pretty amazing that he took the stand, that’s a miracle in itself and it never ceases to amaze me that he is still going strong despite the disease he is fighting.

Wrt the message, I don’t think anyone heard real miracles. The tech blogs predicted most of the stuff announced and Apple didn’t announce any new hardware. Because of this it seems the Tech press is less impressed. I guess it takes an announcement of the size of the iPhone or iPad to get the crowd excited. I am betting that Apple will not be able to reach that excitement in the coming years as the iPhone was such a radical shift in  mobile thinking. You don’t shake up markets like that every year. Everything done after that is logical evolution, and certainly not the revolution the iPhone and iOS brought.

Still, Apple is a company that continuously impresses everyone and I believe it has to do with a uniqueness that separates Apple from everyone else. It isn’t just their exceptional design, creativity or feel for simplicity. It seems to me that Apple is one of a very few companies that successfully integrated development of beautiful and unique hardware with powerful and well designed software. The WWDC  2011 keynote seems like a software catch up to me. After delivering the iPhone and the iPad to the world it was now time to upgrade iOS and Lion and show the world how to integrate all that slick hardware with a unique software platform and the iCloud.

While the tech press may not be super-duper impressed, pampered with cool technology as they are, I feel Apple delivered a platform that integrates hardware, software and services (apps) exceptionally well. It is an amazing accomplishment that will trigger developers to go the extra mile and come up with new innovations no one had thought of before.

There was also some sentiment about Apple taking developers out of business by integrating core functionality from their apps directly into iOS. I doubt any of them were really surprised by the move. Apple has made iOS more complete by this integration and it makes sense to do so. It sucks if it means your app may go out of business, but from Apple’s point of view it is a logical step.

There was the inevitable comparison with Google’s Android (Apple’s new notification center is just like Android’s), although Gruber notes that the biggest difference between Apple and Google is that Apple has chosen the path fo native apps while Google has chosen the browser to be the center of the earth. It sounds like Gruber feels Apple has made the right choice (he definitely likes Apple over Google). I feel that the choice between native and browser will diminish over time. iOS 5 is not the competitive advantage that Apple hold over Google.

The real competitive advantage  is that Apple has a complete, deeply integrated ecology that encompasses both hardware, software, services (apps)  and a huge, profitable market that currently puts them on top of everyone else.

I would still not rule out Google, nor Android, simply because at some point Android will overtake iOS in numbers, not by a small bit, but by a huge factor. Scale always has a way to attract innovation, despite the fact that Android is not half as complete as iOS. It lacks great hardware, super software and a (for developers) profitable market. But scale makes up for a lot of these things, and Android is bound to win the scale game. And that is great news. Apple might not have gone this far, if it didn’t feel the heat of Android.

Funny enough, Microsoft may have understood this even a little better than Google and devised a strategy that involves both hardware (Nokia) and software (WP7). I somehow don’t believe they will pull it off though. It’s too late. Nokia doesn’t have the sexiest hardware anymore, and I doubt that they will catch up anymore. They will build a cool platform together but they might just lose the scale game.

Jobs, indirectly, tells the world that his platform is so much better than Google’s, and because he does that, consumers will profit. Let Apple and Google fight each other in Mobile, and we will all benefit.

For me and my company Zwapp the keynote yesterday was good news. A new platform with new opportunities arises. I’ve already claimed a few domain names because yesterday’s keynote immediately triggered a creative process with me, showing us new opportunities to make a difference. We’ll be building cool stuff on iOS 5 but I can already say that Android will not be forgotten.

Way to go Apple!


About vanelsas

See my about page, ;-)
This entry was posted in Android Mobile OS, Apple, Google, iOS5, iPad, iPhone and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to The competitive advantage Apple holds over Google isn’t iOS5 or iCloud

  1. Pingback: All the New Apple Stuff – Gizmodo « lennyesq

  2. It was all just catch up, and barely even that. It’s still far behind HTC Sense in several areas (but not Android in general, which still, quite frankly, sucks). No Facebook support? Who are they kidding? Who really has “photos of friends” on Twitter? My family has no clue what Twitter even is.

    I had been hoping that HP WebOS, which looks like a far more extendable OS would burst through, but my faith is waning.

    iOS5 is principally interesting due to ARC IMO, nothing else surprised / interested me. The core tech behind iCloud (basically a simple version of Google’s various APIs but with more reach due to the platform to go with it) is also very interesting.

    Here is to hoping that the developers pull it off once again and iOS 5 again becomes a platform that I love. It’s not been up to Apple for a while already after all, it’s all about the apps now.

    • vanelsas says:

      Hey Alex,

      Steve and Mark probably couldn’t reach an agreement 😉 It might get there in time.
      Apple clearly has chosen the App path and I expect great things from developers. It still is a great platform to develop beautiful apps for.

  3. Hey Alex,

    I have to disagree with your statement on great hardware and great software. Most of the hardware is not as as good as competitors hardware (talking cpu, memory, etc). Having a programming language which is based on SmalllTalk doens’t sound hight quality to mee either.
    I think their power is more in the fact that they are very good at simplicity. This way a device becomes more then the sum of it’s components.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s